Lessons in Extra Virgin Olive Oil



Up until this week, I didn’t really give much thought to olive oil, except the acknowledgement that I like it. I’d  just pick up a giant bottle at TJ’s or Whole Foods, so I could get the most bang for my buck, and not think twice.

Well, apparently I should be giving it some more thought, because I recently learned that the “extra virgin olive oil” label is essentially meaningless. Oh, and it may not even be olive oil. What?!

Prepare yourself – I’m about to rock your olive oil world.

According to an interview with olive oil expert Tom Mueller on NPR’s On Point with Tom Ashbrook, most of what’s on the extra virgin olive oil labels is marketing speak, with no actual truth. That Italian flag? It may not even be from Italy. Claiming to be “cold-pressed”? It can’t be cold or else they can’t extract the olive juice and most are using industrial centrifuges, not presses.

Here are a few other things I learned from this interview:

  • High quality extra virgin olive oil needs to be made from olives that have been picked from the trees before the fruit is fully ripened.
  • It must be made into olive oil immediately – how fast the fruit goes from the tree to the mill is more important than where it’s grown.


  • 70% of supermarket olive oils are defective according to a UC Davis study.
  • The vast majority of supermarket olive oils are low grade and often made from olives that have been picked up off of the ground using a street sweeper, after rotting there for 2-3 months.
  • This oil is straight up rancid and because it smells and tastes so bad, it must go through a chemical refining process called “deodorizing”.
  • “Deodorizing” means that it is not “extra virgin” oil, and also leaves the oil tasteless. Because it’s tasteless, it then gets blended with a very small amount of pure extra virgin oil, and is then sold to consumers.

Oh, but there’s more.

  • Some of these olive oils aren’t even olive oils at all. They may be made from cheaper vegetable oils, including soy, peanut, and sunflower oils, which raises a whole other issue of allergy concerns.

Crazy, right?

So, not surprisingly, most of the olive oil we’re buying doesn’t have any of the health benefits we associate with a Mediterranean diet. Additionally, it also doesn’t taste very good.

Towards the end of the interview, the two Toms do a taste test with a typical supermarket brand and a bottle from Boston Olive Oil Company (one of the reasons I included it in my foodie gift swap). Let’s just say describing the supermarket bottle as tasting like “paint thinner”, “musty”, “metallic”, and my favorite – “cat pee” – was enough to make me reconsider buying my olive oil based on price alone.

Sure, it’s more expensive to buy the good stuff (I paid about $18 for a bottle from Boston Olive Oil Company), but I appreciate it so much more knowing what’s gone into it, and I’m treating it like liquid gold. Plus, because it has such a strong (pleasant) flavor, a little goes a long way.

If you have the time, I highly recommend listening to the full NPR interview. It will likely make you think twice about picking up any old bottle of extra virgin olive oil.



Leave a Comment

  1. Say it ain’t so!
    I wonder if the stuff I buy is phony… I usually get Spectrum Organic brand, or something similar to that… but also have Whole Foods and Trader Joes brands in my house.
    There’s an olive oil and vinegar shop near my house that I’d really hope is “pure”- especially since it’s about $18 a bottle as well (and tastes amazing). They have all different types of infusions- it’s amazing!

    1. Amanda says

      I know, I was so bummed when I heard this! I’m not sure if there’s really a good way to tell if it’s phony, other than a taste test. I imagine the organic stuff is a step above the rest though.

  2. Oh boy, rock my olive oil world you did. Sh$t!!! I use this stuff every day, sometimes multiple times a day and usually cringe when I buy the huge container for like $30 (on sale) and now I’m questioning not only the process but the type of oil it actually is! I’ll definitely be checking out this interview.

  3. one of the few advantages of living in Italy: food is respected a bit more and this kind of stuff doesn’t happen!

    1. Amanda says

      True! I think they said somewhere in the interview that Italy actually imports some of it’s olive oil from Greece and Spain because it can’t keep up with demand. I thought that was kind of interesting.

      1. That doesn’t shock me; we have our fare share of imported food, checking the labels for the country of origin is always a good thing!

  4. Lee says

    Really? I always just buy the giant Trader Joe’s bottle too.

  5. well crap. thanks for the info… food bill is gonna go up but I think it’s worth it to make sure we aren’t eating palm oil.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *